Becoming independent would therefore arguably be a step for democracy and for the health and recovery of its economy. Auditor Independence - 2. The First Minister of Essay on scottish independence, Alex Salmond, essay on scottish independence, and the SNP unexpectedly won an historic grand slam — forming the first majority government in the Scottish parliament despite the Scottish system being set up to prevent a party gaining a majority and the only majority government in the whole UK — enabling Mr Salmond to demand an independence referendum. So, why should this be changed, if it can result in many problems of different types. Tell a six million population to apply for a new passport and exchange all of their money to Euros. The assumption that independence is achievable with the costs and problems involved is something the Scottish taxpayer would have to bear the burden of. It currently remains unclear if an independent Scotland would remain part of the British military forces or if it would develop its own military capabilities and consequently an independent defense and security policy.
Popular Topics
Scotland is at a turning point. Some say the union is no longer fit for purpose and it is holding Scotland back. But many people oppose these views saying Scotland needs the rest of the UK and the economic and social factors of independence would be essay on scottish independence great to deal with. Independence for Scotland means that we will have the right to make our own decisions about the future of our own country rather than those decisions being made by politicians in London. In this essay, essay on scottish independence, I will present a fair conclusion by weighing up the arguments for and against Scottish Independence. After many cross-border disputes, including when Scotland was defeated by the English in at Flodden, the Scottish and English crowns we united in when King James IV of Scotland became monarch of the British Isles.
The First Minister of Scotland, Alex Salmond, and the SNP unexpectedly won an historic grand slam — forming the first essay on scottish independence government in the Scottish parliament despite the Scottish system being set up to prevent a party gaining a majority and the only majority government in the whole UK — enabling Mr Salmond to demand an independence referendum. Moreover independence would enable Scotland to become more successful, essay on scottish independence. One of the main reasons more and more people are supporting Scottish Independence is the great economic benefits it would have.
The similarities between Scotland and Norway for example; both having relatively similar populations and large oil, gas and renewable energy resources; show how different Scotland would be if it had control over its own economy. The British government under Margret Thatcher used the money they made from oil and gas to close down the coal and shipbuilding industries in the s and s which caused widespread poverty and unemployment in Scotland and Northern England while the Norwegian government used the profits they made from essay on scottish independence North Sea more wisely to fund a pension fun with? I would like to take a different angle from it now.
In addition, I strongly believe that Britain is arguably structured on extremely undemocratic principles. How is it at all democratic for the UK to have an unequal proportional electoral system in place where nearly seats in parliament are taken up by England and Scotland with 59? Becoming independent would therefore arguably be a step for democracy and for the health and recovery of its economy. The majority of laws which are put in place in Scotland are decided and passed in Westminster by English politicians who will not be affected by these laws and are intended primarily for England without much consideration for Scotland.
At present Scotland has a government that runs lots of Scottish affairs but has one hand tied behind its back with ones not in their control essay on scottish independence such as taxation and fiscal policies. Although Scotland already has control over its own parliament and legal system, it still has no control over its own defence and security. My favourite news recently is that nuclear warheads were transported through Glasgow even though MSPs condemned strongly against this and without informing the local authorities.
The MoD recently carried out a mock-emergency exercise essay on scottish independence took them five hours to complete the task and if something bad had happened with just one of those warheads Glasgow would be uninhabitable for years and years. Independence would see the nuclear weapons gone and therefore the country as a whole would be safer. Tell that to the children living in poverty in your own country. If things stay as they are just now, bychildren will be living in poverty in Scotland — 4 times the population of the Western Isles, essay on scottish independence. Contrary to this and despite the evidence in to show that independence would be beneficial to Scotland there are those who are still unconvinced.
Equally a large number of people regard independence as a huge economic gamble. Free Essays Topics Essay Checker Hire Writer Login. Free essay samples Independence Scottish Independence. Scottish Independence 8 August Hire verified writer. Scottish Independence Essay Example. Related Essays. Discursive Essay on Scottish Essay on scottish independence Scottish Ethics Independence day War for Independence Self Independence Independence Day Independence Independence and Me Declaration Of Independence Independence day speech Mexican War of Independence. A limited time offer! Save Time On Research and Writing, essay on scottish independence. Get My Paper. Popular Topics celebrity family starbucks jewellery nutrition alice in wonderlan adolescence dieting mobile phone customer service.
college goals essay
Some say the union is no longer fit for purpose and it is holding Scotland back. But many people oppose these views saying Scotland needs the rest of the UK and the economic and social factors of independence would be too great to deal with. Independence for Scotland means that we will have the right to make our own decisions about the future of our own country rather than those decisions being made by politicians in London. In this essay, I will present a fair conclusion by weighing up the arguments for and against Scottish Independence. After many cross-border disputes, including when Scotland was defeated by the English in at Flodden, the Scottish and English crowns we united in when King James IV of Scotland became monarch of the British Isles.
The First Minister of Scotland, Alex Salmond, and the SNP unexpectedly won an historic grand slam — forming the first majority government in the Scottish parliament despite the Scottish system being set up to prevent a party gaining a majority and the only majority government in the whole UK — enabling Mr Salmond to demand an independence referendum. Moreover independence would enable Scotland to become more successful. One of the main reasons more and more people are supporting Scottish Independence is the great economic benefits it would have. The similarities between Scotland and Norway for example; both having relatively similar populations and large oil, gas and renewable energy resources; show how different Scotland would be if it had control over its own economy.
The British government under Margret Thatcher used the money they made from oil and gas to close down the coal and shipbuilding industries in the s and s which caused widespread poverty and unemployment in Scotland and Northern England while the Norwegian government used the profits they made from the North Sea more wisely to fund a pension fun with? I would like to take a different angle from it now. In addition, I strongly believe that Britain is arguably structured on extremely undemocratic principles. How is it at all democratic for the UK to have an unequal proportional electoral system in place where nearly seats in parliament are taken up by England and Scotland with 59? Becoming independent would therefore arguably be a step for democracy and for the health and recovery of its economy.
The majority of laws which are put in place in Scotland are decided and passed in Westminster by English politicians who will not be affected by these laws and are intended primarily for England without much consideration for Scotland. At present Scotland has a government that runs lots of Scottish affairs but has one hand tied behind its back with ones not in their control — such as taxation and fiscal policies. Although Scotland already has control over its own parliament and legal system, it still has no control over its own defence and security. My favourite news recently is that nuclear warheads were transported through Glasgow even though MSPs condemned strongly against this and without informing the local authorities. a history of independence or self-rule in an identifiable territory?
a distinct culture? a will and capability to regain self-governance Chapter II Arguments for and against the Scottish independence 1. Arguments for the independence Now I want to speak about the reasons why many Scots consider they should their independence back. First and foremost, Scotland is its own country. It is a distinct country which has its own culture, people, history, traditions, national dress, land and sea borders, health service, legal establishment, education system, flag and a history of nationhood that. This can be seen with it investing in nuclear weapons for the next 35 years at a cost between?
Thus, if Scotland were independent, they would invest their elsewhere. Control over North Sea oil and gas, which is expected to generate? Furthermore, for the next fifty years, renewable energy is seen as a key industry worldwide. Scotland has a strategic position for wind, hydro, and tide powered energy. With over 40 years of North Sea oil still available, the profits could be poured into renewable energy — instead of being sent to London. Nowadays a great rise of nationalism can be observed in Scotland. Thus many Scots stick to the point that if Scotland were to become independent, it would emphasize their greatest individuals, businesses, and achievements instead of having them blended with Westminster politicians.
Arguments against the independence. From all the above mentioned we can conclude that there is obviously a case for Scottish Independence, but before doing this we shall discuss the reason against the Scottish autonomy. People think they should have more control over their own country and demand more rights. However they do have control over their country as they decide on matters like health, education, transport, housing, environment and local affairs. Scottish devolved parliament has been working independently since with no major issues so why should this be changed, if it can bring many problems.
How is that fair? If anyone should be complaining it should be the English. Scotland has its own devolved parliament but also has Labour seats down in Westminster deciding on British and English issues. First of all they are lucky to have as much power as they do being even less than a tenth of the population of Britain. So, why should this be changed, if it can result in many problems of different types. Moreover, for unionists, the main argument against Scottish independence is the Barnett formula — a rule that Scotland receives 10 pence of every pound made in the UK, while only having 8.
Social issues would not be our only problem; Scotland would encounter numerous other issues if we were to become independent. Problems with passports or currency what would be done about them? What would be the solution? Tell a six million population to apply for a new passport and exchange all of their money to Euros. Also problems like defense or immigration and the other issues which affect the whole of the British island which are now dealt with in Westminster. How would separate independent states decide to split these responsibilities? The assumption that independence is achievable with the costs and problems involved is something the Scottish taxpayer would have to bear the burden of.
Another barrier is that numerous commentators have raised the objection that since a vote for independence would affect the entire UK, then residents of England, Wales and Northern Ireland should also be entitled to vote. Others have raised the issue of whether Scots not currently resident in Scotland should have the right to vote. It currently remains unclear if an independent Scotland would remain part of the British military forces or if it would develop its own military capabilities and consequently an independent defense and security policy. However, England potentially has most to lose overall from Scottish independence. If Scotland splits from the rest of the UK and turns out to be relatively viable as an independent country it is possible that Wales, and even Northern Ireland, will follow its example.
Hence, English Eurosceptics who consider Scottish independence as an opportunity to push their country quicker towards EU exit should think again. Scotland might have the last laugh after all. Conclusion Thus, in this research paper I spoke about the issue of Scottish independence. This is a matter of global importance, and in the first chapter of my work I tried to give general information about the history of his question, about the parties which want their country gain independence, about different surveys held on this issue. In the second chapter I represented the major for and against arguments. This arguments help us understand what are the main reasons some Scots want independence and what are the objections. The separation of Britain would provoke competition, bad relationships and ambiguity in various questions.
And in my opinion even if the idea of this independence does have good points for Scotland, this nationalistic pride will only make both Scotland and the rest of the UK more vulnerable. Bibliography 1. html 3. html 1. This essay was written by a fellow student. You can use it as an example when writing your own essay or use it as a source, but you need cite it. Explore how the human body functions as one unit in harmony in order to life. Scottish Independence. Free Essays - PhDessay. com, Apr 09, Accessed January 7, com , Apr The American war for Independence was a new revolution that was relevant for various political and social reasons.
Due to the changes caused by such revolution, the changes that happened.
No comments:
Post a Comment